Come, Let Us Reason Together.
This post is written to provide another opportunity at presenting some of the core principles articulated in R. Nelson Nash's "Becoming Your Own Banker," a text detailing a financial strategy known as the Infinite Banking Concept® (IBC). The central thesis posits that the average individual's most significant financial problem is the vast volume of interest perpetually paid to external banking and finance institutions. The source text calculates that for a typical American, 34.5 cents of every after-tax dollar is paid out in interest for major items such as automobiles and housing.
The Infinite Banking Concept offers a paradigm shift: a method to recapture this banking function by establishing a personal banking system. The primary vehicle for this system is dividend-paying whole life insurance, chosen for its contractual guarantees, tax-deferred growth of cash values, and the policy owner's supreme contractual right to borrow against their equity. By capitalizing a system of policies over time, an individual can finance major purchases through policy loans and repay those loans to their own system with interest, thereby capturing the profits that would otherwise be permanently lost to external lenders.
This strategy is not a "get rich quick" scheme but a long-term, disciplined approach requiring a mindset akin to that of a forester, planning intergenerationally. Its success is contingent not only on understanding the mechanics of life insurance but also on overcoming critical human behavioral pitfalls, including the tendency for expenses to rise with income (Parkinson's Law), the complacency born from the illusion of knowledge (The Arrival Syndrome), and the failure to treat one's own system with the same discipline afforded to a commercial bank.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. The Central Financial Problem: A Perpetual Headwind
The foundational problem identified is not the rate of return on savings but the sheer volume of interest paid out over a lifetime. The text illustrates this with a hypothetical "All-American family" earning $28,500 per year after taxes. An analysis of this family's spending reveals a perpetual financial drain:
• Transportation: 21% of every car payment dollar is interest, a proportion that remains constant as cars are perpetually financed or leased.
• Housing: Over the first five years of a typical 30-year mortgage, 86% of every dollar paid goes toward the cost of financing, a cycle that resets with each new mortgage.
• Living Expenses: Interest on credit cards, boat payments, and other items rivals the volume paid on auto loans.
The cumulative effect is that 34.5 cents of every disposable dollar is paid out as interest. This creates a powerful financial "headwind." The author uses an aviation analogy to explain the severity of this drag:
"You are in Birmingham, AL with an airplane that can fly 100 miles per hour and your destination is Chicago. The only problem is that you have a headwind of 345 miles per hour! Regardless of what your airspeed indicator says, your airplane is moving toward Miami at 245 miles per hour!"
Most financial advice focuses on trying to increase the airplane's speed by a few miles per hour (i.e., chasing higher rates of return on the small percentage of income being saved), while ignoring the overwhelming force of the headwind. The core message of IBC is to eliminate the headwind and create a perpetual "tailwind" by controlling the banking equation.
2. The Infinite Banking Concept (IBC): A Paradigm Shift
IBC is a strategy to control the banking function as it relates to one's own financial needs. It is built on several foundational understandings.
You Finance Everything You Buy
A core tenet of IBC is that every purchase is financed. One either borrows money and pays interest to an external lender, or one uses their own cash and gives up the interest that money could have earned otherwise. This "opportunity cost" is a central concept, also known as Economic Value Added (EVA). The text notes that even major corporations have historically made the error of treating their own equity capital as if it had no cost, to their detriment.
Recapturing the Banking Function
The objective of IBC is to create a private system where the individual can recapture the interest and principal that flows through their hands. Instead of paying interest to a commercial bank's stockholders, the individual pays it back into an entity they own and control.
"The whole idea is to recapture the interest that one is paying to banks and finance companies for the major items that we need during a lifetime, such as automobiles, major appliances, education, homes, investment opportunities, business equipment, etc."
3. The Chosen Vehicle: Dividend-Paying Whole Life Insurance
The mechanism for implementing IBC is participating (dividend-paying) whole life insurance issued by a mutual company. This specific financial product is chosen for a unique combination of contractual features.
• Control: The policy owner has absolute control and ranks first in the hierarchy of borrowers. The owner can borrow 100% of their equity in the contract at any time for any reason.
• Guaranteed Growth: The policy's cash value is guaranteed to grow and ultimately equal the face amount of the policy by age 100.
• Dividends: Mutual life insurance companies are owned by the policyholders. When the company's experience (mortality, expenses, investment returns) is better than projected, the surplus is returned to policy owners as a dividend. This is legally classified as a return of premium, not taxable income. These dividends can be used to purchase "Paid-Up Additional Insurance," which accelerates the growth of both cash value and the death benefit on a tax-deferred basis.
• Co-generation Analogy: Creating a banking system with life insurance is compared to a paper mill using its wood waste for "co-generation" to produce its own electricity. Rather than building a new utility from scratch, it taps into an existing, efficient system. IBC taps into the existing, 200-year-old infrastructure of the life insurance industry.
Optimal Policy Design
For IBC purposes, the policy should be engineered to maximize cash value, not just the initial death benefit. This is achieved by structuring the policy to get as much premium into it as possible with the least amount of insurance. The recommended method is to add a Paid-Up Additions Rider (PUA) to a base policy (such as ordinary life). This strategy allows the owner to "snuggle up to the MEC line"—the limit defined by the IRS for a policy to retain its tax-favored status—without crossing it.
Critique of Other Products
The text explicitly warns against using Universal Life or Variable Life for IBC.
• Universal Life: Criticized as "one-year term insurance with a side fund," its illustrations were noted to "fall apart" at older ages when the cost of insurance becomes prohibitive.
• Variable Life: Described as "one-year term insurance with a side fund of a mutual fund," it is rejected for exposing the policy's cash value to market risk and the performance of fund managers.
4. The Analogy of the Grocery Store: Principles of Operation
To illustrate the necessary business discipline, the text presents a detailed analogy of starting and running a grocery store. The key lessons are directly applicable to managing a personal banking system:
1. High Capitalization: A successful business requires significant initial capital and time before it becomes profitable.
2. Being Both Consumer and Seller: The store owner is also a customer. This creates a potential conflict.
3. The Cardinal Rule: When the owner's family needs groceries, they must go through the "front door" and pay the full retail price like any other customer. Taking goods out the "back door" is theft and will destroy the business.
This translates directly to IBC: when a policy owner takes a loan, they are acting as a borrower from their own bank. They must repay that loan with interest at a fair market rate. Failure to do so is the equivalent of stealing from the grocery store and will "kill the best business in the world."
"If the policyholder objects that, 'it’s my own money and I am not going to pay any interest at all' ... then the agent must remind him of the grocery store that went broke ... Loans have to be paid back or you can kill the best business in the world."
5. Implementation Strategy: Automobile Financing Example
The text demonstrates the long-term power of IBC through a 44-year comparison of five methods for financing automobiles.
Method
Description
44-Year Net Cost
Method A
Leasing cars continuously.
Est. $175,000
Method B
Financing through a commercial bank.
$137,280
Method C
Paying cash from a sinking fund.
$124,300
Method D
Self-financing using Certificates of Deposit (CDs).
$25,188
Method E
Infinite Banking using whole life insurance.
($511,624) Net Gain
Methods A, B, and C, which represent how over 90% of the population operates, result in a significant net cost. Methods D and E involve a 7-year capitalization period of paying $5,000 annually before financing begins.
• Method D (CDs): While far superior to paying cash, this method enriches the stockholders of the commercial bank where the CDs are held. The account holder only earns interest.
• Method E (IBC): In this method, the policy owner acts as both the C/D holder (earning guaranteed cash value growth) and the bank stockholder (earning dividends). While Method D appears superior in the early years due to the acquisition costs of starting a life insurance policy, Method E dramatically outperforms it over the long term. By year 51, the IBC policy has a cash value of $964,638 compared to the CD account′s $258,927, plus a substantial death benefit.
This example illustrates that by using IBC, the individual captures the profits that would otherwise go to the bank's owners, creating a dramatically superior financial outcome.
6. The Human Element: Overcoming Behavioral Obstacles
The text dedicates significant attention to the "human problems" that must be overcome for IBC to succeed. These are fundamental aspects of human nature that work against long-term financial discipline.
• Parkinson’s Law: The observation that "expenses rise to equal income" and "a luxury, once enjoyed, becomes a necessity." Without actively combating this tendency, any increase in income is consumed, leaving no surplus to capitalize the banking system.
• Willie Sutton’s Law: "Wherever wealth is accumulated someone will try to steal it." The text identifies the primary practitioner of "legal plunder" as the government through confiscatory taxation. IBC, using a private contract (life insurance) that predates the income tax, is presented as a superior way to protect wealth from this threat compared to government-created "solutions" like 401(k)s and IRAs.
• The Golden Rule: A pragmatic interpretation that "those who have the Gold make the rules." This underscores the importance of accumulating capital to gain financial control and avoid being at the mercy of external lenders.
• The Arrival Syndrome: The most devastating obstacle, described as "the illusion of knowledge." This is the tendency to be "too well pleased with ourselves," stop learning, and dismiss new paradigms like IBC with a superficial "but we are already doing that." True understanding requires multiple readings and an open mind.
• Use It Or Lose It: IBC must become a way of life, not a casual tactic. Like any skill or business, it requires consistent application and discipline to be effective. The failure to consistently apply the principles is a primary reason for lack of success.